Impact Windows vs. Hurricane Shutters: Which Is Better for Florida Homes?
Living in Florida means being prepared for hurricane season. If you're a homeowner looking to protect your property, you've likely considered two popular options: impact-resistant windows and hurricane shutters. But which is the better investment?
In this article, we’ll break down the pros and cons of each, and help you decide which option makes the most sense for your home.
🪟 What Are Impact Windows?
Impact windows, also known as hurricane windows, are made with laminated, reinforced glass designed to resist flying debris and extreme pressure changes during a storm. They’re permanently installed in place of your existing windows and look just like standard residential windows, but with serious protection built in.
Key Features:
Laminated glass with a durable interlayer
Tested to meet Florida Building Code and wind-load requirements
Available in a range of styles and frame finishes
🛡️ What Are Hurricane Shutters?
Hurricane shutters are removable or deployable coverings that protect your existing windows during a storm. Common types include accordion shutters, roll-down shutters, storm panels, and even plywood.
Key Features:
Installed over or around existing windows
Available in manual or motorized options
Require deployment before each storm
🆚 Comparing the Two Options
1. Storm Protection
Impact Windows: Always ready; no prep needed. Protects against wind, debris, and pressure changes 24/7.
Hurricane Shutters: Provide strong protection if deployed correctly, but you must act before each storm.
✅ Winner: Impact windows (no setup required)
2. Appearance
Impact Windows: Look and function like regular windows — clean, modern, and attractive year-round.
Shutters: Can be bulky, visible, or require storage space when not in use.
✅ Winner: Impact windows
3. Energy Efficiency
Impact Windows: Provide insulation and UV protection, helping to lower energy bills in hot Florida weather.
Shutters: Offer no thermal benefits unless left closed (not practical year-round).
✅ Winner: Impact windows
4. Cost
Impact Windows: Higher upfront investment, but offer long-term value.
Shutters: Lower initial cost, but may require maintenance or replacement, and don’t address energy or noise.
✅ Winner: Depends on your budget
5. Insurance & Code Compliance
Both can help lower your insurance premiums if properly rated.
Impact windows can satisfy more comprehensive building code upgrades, especially in wind-borne debris zones.
✅ Winner: Impact windows (more versatile)
💬 Our Recommendation
At Artisan Windows & Doors, we recommend impact windows for most Florida homeowners, especially those in Brooksville, Spring Hill, and coastal areas where storm prep needs to be fast, reliable, and low maintenance.
They provide year-round protection, improve energy efficiency, and boost your home’s curb appeal, all while meeting Florida Building Code standards.
🛠️ Already Have Shutters? You Can Still Upgrade
If you currently use shutters but want to upgrade, we offer custom-fit impact window replacements from top-rated brands like CWS Comfort Shield, built specifically for Florida’s climate and storm requirements.
📞 Ready to Upgrade Your Protection?
Contact Artisan Windows & Doors for a free, low-pressure consultation. We'll help you understand your options and recommend the best solution for your home, budget, and location.
